Skip to content

[comment] Lemire's string escape check #5

@prlw1

Description

@prlw1

Just for your amusement...

I was intrigured by Daniel Lemire's blog post on checking whether a string needs escaping, in which he provides a benchmark including optimised SSE2 code.

For fun I tried what I hope is the rather more readable equivalent using <simd>:

#include <simd>
inline bool stdsimd_needs_escaping(std::string_view view) {
  using V = std::datapar::simd<std::string_view::value_type, 16>;
  if (view.size() < V::size()) {
    return simple_needs_escaping(view);
  }
  auto it = view.begin();
  std::datapar::simd_mask<std::string_view::value_type, 16> running{false};
  for (; it + V::size() <= view.end(); it += V::size) {
    V word(std::datapar::unchecked_load<V>(it, V::size()));
    running = running || (word == V{34});
    running = running || (word == V{92});
    //running = running || (std::sub_sat(word,V{31}) == V{0});
    running = running || (word <  V{32});
  }
  if (it < view.end()) {
    V word(std::datapar::unchecked_load<V>(view.data() + view.length() - V::size(), V::size()));
    running = running || (word == V{34});
    running = running || (word == V{92});
    //running = running || (std::sub_sat(word,V{31}) == V{0});
    running = running || (word <  V{32});
  }
  return std::datapar::any_of(running);
}

and obtained a pleasing

simple_needs_escaping                    :   0.74 GB/s   32.4 Ma/s  30.82 ns/d 
branchless_needs_escaping                :   0.89 GB/s   39.1 Ma/s  25.58 ns/d 
table_needs_escaping                     :   2.39 GB/s  104.5 Ma/s   9.57 ns/d 
SIMD implementation is correct: 1 1
simd_needs_escaping                      :   4.90 GB/s  214.8 Ma/s   4.66 ns/d 
std::SIMD implementation is correct: 1 1
std:simd_needs_escaping                  :   4.31 GB/s  188.9 Ma/s   5.29 ns/d 

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions