Skip to content

ready message has a race condition #26

@EamonNerbonne

Description

@EamonNerbonne

The code transmitting "ready!" assumes that it may never receive a ready signal from the opposite side when it is ready.
Normally, this is OK, and the flow is roughtly:

(A) comes online, sends "ping"
(B) not online yet, "ping" lost.
(B) comes online, sends "ping"
(A) receives B's ping; ready=true; sends "pong"
(B) receives A's pong; ready=true

However, this assumption can fail when A+B come online around the same time:

(A) comes online, sends "ping"
(B) comes online, sends "ping"
(B) receives A's ping; ready=true; sends "pong"
(A) receives B's ping; ready=true; sends "pong"
(B) receives A's pong but is ready throws exception
(A) receives B's pong but is ready throws exception

Notably, this can happen because there's no guarrantee of a single thread of execution across windows/frames/web-worker, and even if there were, there is no guarrantee that execution of a postMessage handler is immediately after the sending of a message - there may simply be non-stop execution or other event handers which cause (B) to come online before the message is handled.

Fix: don't throw an exception when this happens.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions