Request: Provide full example code / reference implementation for PRFC 1-3

[chilligerchief]

Hello,
I wanted to implement my own PRFC1 token. However, i found that the documentation for all PRFCs is quite sparse.

I would have expected a reference implementation for all PRFC standard contracts that I can easly adapt instead of implementing each function on my own. Can you provide these implementations i this repository?

Best regards

[lyulka]

Thanks for the interest in writing ParallelChain contracts, @chilligerchief.

We do plan on publishing example implementations for each of the PRFC token standards, but both PRFC 1 and PRFC 2 are currently still subject to change (perhaps we should make this more clear in the specification documents, my apologies).

So, the example implementations will have to wait until after the PRFC 1 and PRFC 2 specifications have been built up to a point where we're confident that the standard can remain unchanged at least in the near term.

[chilligerchief]

Thanks for the quick reply. What about the implementation for PRFC3? As far as I know there are already contracts deployed on the mainnet for lockup / vesting? If so, can you upload that or share that with me?

Additionally, is there some way I can still get an example implementation for PRFC1? There is also already a contract deployed on the testnet, that I can interact with.

Finally, since the PRFC1 standard is quite similar to ERC20, which works fine for years, is there really a realistic chance that this will change in the future?

If you can not share this with me at the moment, what ist the timeline for providing this?

Best regards

[chilligerchief]

@lyulka if you cant give feedback on PRFC1 and 2 can you at least provide more information on PRFC3? as I stated it seems to be in use already?

[lyulka]

@chilligerchief, apologies for the late reply. I've asked around and as of now, I can give you a clear answer about PRFC 2 and PRFC 3:

• PRFC 2: we've written a sample implementation, and it is now under internal review. After the review completes, we will publish both: (i). The final specification of version 4 of the standard, and (ii). The sample implementation, into this repository. If everything goes according to plan, you can expect these within the next 2 weeks. I'll tag you in this repository after they're released.
• PRFC 3: implementations of PRFC 3 standard are indeed already in use. However, our organization considers these production implementations proprietary code, and we do not have plans to open-source them as of this moment. Technically, we could write a sample implementation for this standard, but since PRFC 3 has kind of a niche use case, we don't think it's the right priority to focus our efforts towards at this moment.

As for PRFC 1, I'm sorry that I can't give you an answer now, but I will get back to you next week.

[chilligerchief]

Thanks again for the answer.

PRFC1: Do you have any updates on this yet? I read in the telegram group that a hackathon is coming up soon. I think it would be extremely improtant that the sample implementation would be available before the hackathon!

PRFC2: Looking forward for more details, Do you have any updates on that, or should that be released any moment?

PRFC3: It is very unfortunate, that you keep this code proprietary.... I wonder, since you consider this a nieche usecase, why you even standardized this. Thanks for the answer anyway, this cleared things up for me.