by Peter Kahl, 2025-07-24; v3: 2025-08-20
This paper introduces Epistemic Clientelism Theory (ECT), my original theoretical framework designed explicitly to analyse the systemic delegation of epistemic agency within academic institutions through entrenched political power dynamics. I argue that academic hierarchies institutionalise epistemic clientelism—a strategic yet coerced exchange in which scholars surrender epistemic autonomy to institutional authorities in return for professional recognition, material resources, and symbolic rewards. Building rigorously upon my foundational scholarship, particularly Epistemic Justice and Institutional Responsibility in Academia (2025) and Directors’ Epistemic Duties and Fiduciary Openness (2025), I synthesise fiduciary theory, democratic epistemology, Joseph Raz’s service conception of legitimate authority, Michel Foucault’s critique of disciplinary power/knowledge structures, Martin Heidegger’s authenticity versus institutional alienation, psychological theories of conformity (Milgram, Zimbardo), systems theory, political clientelism literature (Scott, Stokes), and script theory (Schank and Abelson). The analysis explicitly demonstrates how epistemic clientelism constitutes profound fiduciary breaches within academia, systematically marginalises alternative epistemological frameworks, undermines scholarly authenticity, and erodes democratic epistemological practices. To address these entrenched institutional failures, I conclude with assertive fiduciary-epistemic governance reforms explicitly designed to dismantle epistemic clientelism, restore epistemic autonomy, revitalise inclusive and participatory knowledge production, and reassert academia’s fiduciary accountability to truth, fairness, and democratic epistemic ideals.
Epistemic Clientelism Theory (ECT), epistemic agency, epistemic autonomy, epistemic justice, fiduciary theory, fiduciary-epistemic governance, fiduciary accountability, power dynamics, academic conformity, democratic epistemology, political epistemology, Joseph Raz, Michel Foucault, Martin Heidegger, psychological conformity, script theory, institutional governance, academic gatekeeping, epistemic marginalisation, knowledge politics, scholarly authenticity, institutional alienation, systems theory, institutional ethics
This is a provisional draft circulated for discussion; readers are welcome to cite it, noting that revisions may follow in later versions.
Kahl, P. (2025). Epistemic clientelism theory: Power dynamics and the delegation of epistemic agency in academia (v3). Lex et Ratio Ltd. GitHub: https://github.com/Peter-Kahl/Epistemic-Clientelism-Theory DOI: https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.27630.88642
First published in Great Britain by Peter Kahl, 2025-07-24.
v3 edition published by Lex et Ratio Ltd on 2025-08-20.
© 2025 Lex et Ratio Ltd. Licensed under Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0.
You may share this work for non-commercial purposes with attribution and without modification.
Licence available at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ .