Skip to content

Conversation

@slayer
Copy link
Owner

@slayer slayer commented Oct 14, 2025

Summary

This PR adds comprehensive testing infrastructure and improvements to the telegram filesystem backend, achieving ~81% code coverage for production code.

Changes

🧪 Testing Infrastructure (New Files)

  1. test_helpers.go (210 lines)

    • testLogger: Full logging implementation for tests with thread-safe log collection
    • MockBot: Mock Telegram bot interface (prepared for future mocking strategies)
    • Helper functions: createTestBot(), createTestAccess(), createTestAccessWithToken()
  2. telegram_test.go (640 lines)

    • 22 comprehensive unit tests covering:
      • Fake filesystem operations and concurrency safety
      • File read/write operations with mutex protection
      • File extension matching (images, videos, audio, text)
      • Size limits and validation
      • Error conditions and edge cases
  3. telegram_integration_test.go (392 lines)

    • 13 integration tests covering:
      • LoadFs parameter validation (empty token, invalid ChatID)
      • File extension detection for all supported types
      • File size validation (50MB Telegram limit)
      • Text size limit enforcement (4096 chars)
      • Filesystem operations (Create, Write, Read, Stat)
      • Multiple file creation workflows

🔧 Code Improvements

Error Handling

  • Use os.ErrNotExist consistently in Stat() and LstatIfPossible()
  • Add ErrFileTooLarge error for size limit violations
  • Add UTF-8 validation for text files before sending to Telegram
  • Proper error wrapping with context

Safety Features

  • File size validation (50MB Telegram limit) in Write()
  • Named constants: maxFileSize, maxTextSize, defaultDirSize
  • Mutex protection for concurrent File read/write operations
  • Graceful bot shutdown with Stop() method and channel signaling

Code Cleanup

  • Remove dead code in fake_fs.go
  • Add security warnings to bot command handlers
  • Improve code documentation
  • Better imports organization

🚀 CI/CD Improvement

  • Clean up .github/workflows/build.yml by removing unnecessary apt-get command
  • Add clarifying comment that GCC is pre-installed on ubuntu-24.04 runners

Test Results

Coverage

  • Total Tests: 35 (13 new integration + 22 new unit tests)
  • Status: ✅ All passing
  • Race Detector: ✅ No race conditions detected
  • Coverage: ~81% of production code (telegram.go, file_info.go, fake_fs.go)

Coverage Breakdown

fake_fs.go:      100.0% ✅
file_info.go:    100.0% ✅ 
telegram.go:      ~72% ✅

Note: Uncovered code (~19%) consists of:

  • Actual Telegram Bot.Send() calls (require network/credentials)
  • Bot command handlers (require complex test poller setup)
  • LoadFs bot initialization with real token (requires network)

These are intentionally excluded from unit tests and should be tested manually or via E2E tests.

Testing Strategy

The tests follow a pragmatic approach using:

  • Offline bot mode for testing LoadFs parameter validation
  • In-memory fake filesystem for testing file operations without I/O
  • Extension detection tests to verify correct file type routing
  • Size validation tests to enforce Telegram limits
  • Thread safety tests with race detector

This achieves high coverage without requiring actual Telegram credentials or network access.

Documentation

  • Added TESTING_PROPOSAL.md with comprehensive testing strategy documentation (available locally, not committed to avoid clutter)

Breaking Changes

None. All changes are backward compatible.

Related Issues

Fixes the panic issue from commit a202228 and improves overall code quality and testability.

slayer added 5 commits August 8, 2024 12:07
…ystem

- Add telegram_test.go with 640 lines of unit tests covering:
  * Fake filesystem operations and concurrency
  * File read/write operations with thread safety
  * File extension matching
  * Size limits and validation
  * Error conditions and edge cases

- Improve error handling:
  * Use os.ErrNotExist consistently in Stat/LstatIfPossible
  * Add ErrFileTooLarge for size limit violations
  * Add UTF-8 validation for text files

- Add safety features:
  * File size validation (50MB Telegram limit)
  * Message size constant (4096 chars)
  * Directory size constant (4096 bytes)
  * Mutex protection for File read/write operations

- Code cleanup:
  * Remove commented-out code in fake_fs.go
  * Add security warnings to bot command handlers
  * Improve imports organization
  * Add graceful bot shutdown with Stop() method
  Test Files Created:

  1. test_helpers.go (210 lines) - Test infrastructure including:
    - testLogger - Full logging implementation for tests
    - MockBot - Mock Telegram bot for testing (prepared for future use)
    - Helper functions: createTestBot(), createTestAccess(), createTestAccessWithToken()
  2. telegram_integration_test.go (392 lines) - Integration tests with 13 new test functions:
    - LoadFs validation (empty token, invalid ChatID)
    - File extension detection (images, videos, audio, text, documents)
    - File size validation and limits
    - Text size limit enforcement
    - Filesystem operations
    - Multiple file creation
    - File read/write integration
@slayer slayer marked this pull request as draft October 14, 2025 21:45
@slayer slayer requested a review from Copilot October 14, 2025 21:45
Copy link

Copilot AI left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull Request Overview

This PR adds comprehensive testing infrastructure and improvements to the telegram filesystem backend, achieving ~81% code coverage for production code. It introduces robust testing capabilities using offline bot mode and in-memory fake filesystem operations, while also improving error handling, safety features, and code organization.

  • Implements comprehensive testing infrastructure with 35 unit and integration tests
  • Adds safety features including file size validation and UTF-8 validation for text files
  • Improves error handling with consistent os.ErrNotExist usage and proper error wrapping
  • Introduces graceful bot shutdown mechanism and thread-safe file operations

Reviewed Changes

Copilot reviewed 7 out of 7 changed files in this pull request and generated 2 comments.

Show a summary per file
File Description
test_helpers.go New test infrastructure with mock logger and bot implementations
telegram_test.go New comprehensive unit tests covering filesystem operations and concurrency
telegram_integration_test.go New integration tests for parameter validation and file type detection
telegram.go Core improvements including safety features, error handling, and thread safety
file_info.go Minor improvement replacing magic number with named constant
fake_fs.go Code cleanup removing dead code comments
.github/workflows/build.yml CI cleanup removing unnecessary apt-get command

Tip: Customize your code reviews with copilot-instructions.md. Create the file or learn how to get started.

slayer and others added 2 commits October 14, 2025 14:46
Co-authored-by: Copilot <175728472+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
- Add sync.Once to Fs struct to prevent double-close panic
- Update Stop() method to use sync.Once.Do()
- Add documentation that Stop() is safe to call multiple times
- Add TestFsStopMultipleCalls to verify thread-safe behavior
- Test verifies concurrent calls to Stop() don't panic

This fixes a potential race condition where calling Stop() multiple
times would cause a panic when trying to close an already-closed channel.
@slayer
Copy link
Owner Author

slayer commented Oct 14, 2025

Additional Fix: Race Condition in Stop() Method

Added protection against multiple calls to Stop() to prevent panic on double-close of channel.

Changes:

  • Added sync.Once field to Fs struct
  • Modified Stop() to use sync.Once.Do() for idempotent shutdown
  • Added TestFsStopMultipleCalls to verify thread-safe behavior

Why This Matters:

Calling Stop() multiple times on the same Fs instance would previously panic when trying to close an already-closed channel. With sync.Once, the cleanup code runs exactly once, making Stop() safe to call multiple times concurrently.

Test Results: ✅ All 36 tests passing with race detector

@slayer slayer requested a review from Copilot October 14, 2025 21:51
Copy link

Copilot AI left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull Request Overview

Copilot reviewed 7 out of 7 changed files in this pull request and generated 3 comments.

Comments suppressed due to low confidence (1)

fs/telegram/telegram.go:1

  • Add comments explaining these are Telegram's API limits to provide context for why these specific values are used.
// Package telegram provides a telegram access layer

Tip: Customize your code reviews with copilot-instructions.md. Create the file or learn how to get started.

slayer and others added 4 commits October 15, 2025 00:35
Co-authored-by: Copilot <175728472+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Copilot <175728472+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
- Change from byte length (len()) to character count (utf8.RuneCountInString())
- Telegram's 4096 limit is characters/runes, not bytes
- Add TestTextSizeLimitUTF8 to verify emoji, Cyrillic, ASCII handling
- Update maxTextSize documentation to clarify it's character limit

This fix allows:
- Emoji text up to 16KB in bytes (4096 chars × 4 bytes)
- Cyrillic text up to 8KB in bytes (4096 chars × 2 bytes)
- ASCII text up to 4KB in bytes (4096 chars × 1 byte)

Previously, non-ASCII text was incorrectly rejected when it exceeded
4096 bytes, even if it was under 4096 characters.
Add comprehensive end-to-end testing setup:

- e2e-test.sh: Automated test script that builds server, creates test
  files (PNG, TXT, MD, MP4, JSON), uploads via FTP, and verifies delivery
- E2E-TESTING.md: Complete documentation with prerequisites, setup
  instructions, and troubleshooting guide
- TESTING_PROPOSAL.md: Testing strategy documentation
- .gitignore: Exclude test artifacts and binaries

The E2E script includes:
- Prerequisites checking (lftp, config validation)
- Automatic server lifecycle management
- Multiple file type testing
- Manual verification workflow
- Robust cleanup with trap handlers
- Colorful status output

Usage: ./fs/telegram/e2e-test.sh
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants