Skip to content

Conversation

@divyaa2809
Copy link

No description provided.

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

  1. Correctness:

    • Exercise_1.py: The stack implementation using a list is correct and handles edge cases like empty stack for pop() and peek(). The show() method returns a copy, which is good practice to prevent external modifications.
    • Exercise_2.py: The linked list stack implementation is mostly correct but lacks some functionality like isEmpty(), peek(), and size() which would be expected in a complete stack implementation.
    • Exercise_3.py: The singly linked list implementation is correct for append(), find(), and remove() operations. The remove() method correctly handles the case where the key is at the head.
  2. Time Complexity:

    • Exercise_1.py: Correctly documented and implemented with O(1) for most operations except show() which is O(n).
    • Exercise_2.py: push() and pop() are correctly O(1) but missing documentation.
    • Exercise_3.py: Correctly implements O(n) for append(), find(), and remove() but missing documentation.
  3. Space Complexity:

    • Exercise_1.py: Correctly documented as O(n).
    • Exercise_2.py: Should be O(n) but not documented.
    • Exercise_3.py: Should be O(n) but not documented.
  4. Code Quality:

    • Exercise_1.py: Well-structured and readable with good comments.
    • Exercise_2.py: Could benefit from more methods (isEmpty, peek) and comments/documentation.
    • Exercise_3.py: Good structure but could use more comments, especially for the remove() method which has non-trivial logic.
  5. Efficiency:

    • Exercise_1.py: No obvious improvements needed.
    • Exercise_2.py: Could add more stack functionality for completeness.
    • Exercise_3.py: Consider adding a tail pointer to make append() O(1).

Areas for Improvement:

  • Add documentation/comments for time and space complexity in Exercise_2.py and Exercise_3.py
  • Complete the stack implementation in Exercise_2.py with standard methods
  • Consider adding a tail pointer in Exercise_3.py for O(1) appends
  • Add more comments explaining non-trivial logic, especially in remove()

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants