Skip to content

Conversation

@kkhevna9252
Copy link

No description provided.

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

  1. Correctness:

    • Exercise_1.java: The stack implementation using an array is correct. It handles stack overflow and underflow conditions appropriately.
    • Exercise_2.java: The stack implementation using a linked list is correct. It properly manages push, pop, and peek operations with appropriate error handling.
    • Exercise_3.java: The linked list implementation is correct for insertion and printing operations.
  2. Time Complexity:

    • Exercise_1.java: Correctly identified as O(1) for push, pop, and peek operations.
    • Exercise_2.java: Correctly identified as O(1) for push, pop, and peek operations.
    • Exercise_3.java: Correctly identified as O(n) for insertion and printing operations.
  3. Space Complexity:

    • Exercise_1.java: Correctly identified as O(MAX) for the array size.
    • Exercise_2.java: Correctly identified as O(n) for the number of nodes.
    • Exercise_3.java: Correctly identified as O(n) for the number of nodes.
  4. Code Quality:

    • The code is generally well-structured and readable.
    • Comments are present and helpful, though some methods could benefit from more detailed explanations.
    • The use of static methods in Exercise_3.java might be reconsidered for better object-oriented design.
    • Variable names are clear and appropriate.
  5. Efficiency:

    • Exercise_1.java: Efficient use of an array for stack operations.
    • Exercise_2.java: Efficient use of a linked list for stack operations.
    • Exercise_3.java: The insertion method could be optimized by maintaining a tail pointer to avoid O(n) traversal for each insertion.

Areas for Improvement:

  • Exercise_3.java: Consider adding a tail pointer to the LinkedList class to make insertions O(1) instead of O(n).
  • Exercise_3.java: The static methods might be better as instance methods for better encapsulation.
  • Exercise_1.java and Exercise_2.java: Consider adding more edge case tests in the main methods to ensure robustness.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants