Skip to content

Conversation

@Bhuvankurra
Copy link

No description provided.

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

The student's solution demonstrates a good understanding of basic data structures and their implementations. Here's a detailed evaluation:

  1. Correctness:
  • Exercise_1.py: The stack implementation using a list is correct and handles edge cases like empty stack for pop() and peek().
  • Exercise_2.py: The linked list implementation of stack is correct with proper push/pop operations.
  • Exercise_3.py: The singly linked list implementation is correct with proper append, find, and remove operations.
  1. Time Complexity:
  • The student has correctly identified time complexities for all operations in each file.
  • Exercise_1.py: All operations except show() are O(1), show() is O(n) - correct.
  • Exercise_2.py: push/pop are O(1) - correct.
  • Exercise_3.py: append/find/remove are O(n) - correct.
  1. Space Complexity:
  • Space complexities are correctly identified for all implementations.
  • The student correctly notes that space complexity is O(n) where n is the number of elements.
  1. Code Quality:
  • Good use of comments and docstrings.
  • Proper class and method naming.
  • Consistent indentation and formatting.
  • Could improve by adding more docstrings in Exercise_2.py to explain methods.
  • The test cases could be more comprehensive to cover edge cases.
  1. Efficiency:
  • All implementations are efficient for their respective data structures.
  • No major optimizations needed, though some small improvements could be made:
    • In Exercise_3.py, remove() could return a boolean to indicate success/failure.
    • In Exercise_2.py, adding a size() method would be useful.

Additional suggestions:

  • Consider adding type hints for better code documentation.
  • Add more edge case testing (e.g., removing non-existent elements in Exercise_3.py).
  • In Exercise_2.py, consider adding input validation for the push operation.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants