Skip to content

Conversation

@mexemexe
Copy link

@mexemexe mexemexe commented Jun 5, 2025

Add Comprehensive API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Task

Include API Endpoint Error Handling Documentation

Acceptance Criteria

  • List common HTTP status codes that might be returned
  • Provide descriptions for each potential error code
  • Include an example of an error response
  • Explain any specific error handling mechanisms

Summary of Work

Overview

This pull request adds a comprehensive API error handling documentation section to the project README, providing developers with detailed guidance on handling API errors effectively.

Changes Made

  • Added a new section "API Error Handling" to the README
  • Documented error response structure
  • Provided detailed HTTP status code explanations
  • Included best practices for error handling
  • Added practical code examples
  • Outlined error monitoring and troubleshooting strategies

Implementation Details

Error Response Structure

  • Created a standardized JSON error response format
  • Included fields for error code, message, and optional details
  • Demonstrated the structure with clear examples

HTTP Status Codes

  • Documented client-side (4xx) error codes:
    • 400 Bad Request
    • 401 Unauthorized
    • 403 Forbidden
    • 404 Not Found
    • 422 Unprocessable Entity
  • Documented server-side (5xx) error codes:
    • 500 Internal Server Error
    • 503 Service Unavailable

Error Handling Best Practices

  • Provided a JavaScript example of robust error checking
  • Outlined key strategies for error handling
    • Logging
    • User-friendly messaging
    • Retry mechanisms
    • Error boundary implementation

Example Scenarios

  • Included detailed examples of:
    • Authentication errors
    • Validation errors

Additional Guidance

  • Added sections on:
    • Error monitoring recommendations
    • Troubleshooting steps

Acceptance Criteria

✓ Comprehensive error handling documentation
✓ Clear, structured explanation of error scenarios
✓ Practical code examples
✓ Best practices for error management
✓ Actionable troubleshooting guidance

Testing Approach

As this is documentation-based implementation:

  • Manual review of documentation completeness
  • Verification of technical accuracy
  • Ensuring clarity and readability

Considerations

  • Documentation is language-agnostic
  • Provides general best practices applicable to most API integrations
  • Can be easily adapted to specific project needs

Next Steps

  • Integrate with existing API documentation
  • Consider expanding with project-specific error details
  • Potentially create a more detailed error handling guide

Changes Made

  • Added comprehensive API error handling section to README
  • Documented error response structure
  • Explained HTTP status codes
  • Provided error handling best practices
  • Included code examples for error scenarios
  • Added troubleshooting and monitoring guidance

Tests

  • Verify documentation covers all major error scenarios
  • Check that error response examples are clear and consistent
  • Ensure best practices are well-explained
  • Validate technical accuracy of error descriptions

Signatures

Staking Key

7odvcXaY5MbxwaefSoKmuBKSWB2tpuWLZC9qTV1M3u8Z: 3n9bahRdFW6vympwnYUQQ4u5bahPBewZL4hPZn9akDb1n7TpPKGJ2ruJHaHjbGE8KMUPST8FQ4mPxbK2Wt5F53s4UrL6Bbb5yHVF3ratd5azbMKJecgzupoJxw8KK64wo8Kf74GoN2fGJztDWFQjvtHNK7QueUoBQYVKK3EhsZNTs4Aky63DhXASWwTtoUhQwnZqEzo9iyUszWvjeoXzdj5RKZEnPjXKqPLDM6NxJ4AnWzJhae77LcbibSRbgDpyQkBtkHDEzw5Seh7q2fB5QYRXRbvp16r7N3ztK5scEkgBigjK4ekW5TJWzk9TvejCq35HH9oNH2KAvVxUQGMPsJqN5PT3dwS1RU813ySi7zBqG8dqAGU5c2b8w6SCqvfEuvsND3DXvStmVSe92GoYtCHKEdefbjvnP6

Public Key

2888VAbnrTxeBqTX2ZNVzbxLPKG5EpCWdsmPiXy1gxGN: QZpKJwcX7twD7FEs67NTyNYceZhxZRGtKnuXcB2PLV5ohWBg9AvNeq1Ja8aUKFevt9Wqw5UPPDuNtrNd2vK1HRakdDCr3gBkjNgBKU5ikgL7xozDDDAsXdVTRafxerZEd8cu1b4GiJYGvR4F1kmAsiBt1zmpa3FU8Ngd29hVws2nxoj6fBcC5Yex1bNRBHjLCnzV3y8hC8JnGXLpQLaiw3Yq7UGGB7p8w9WLxenUtnHqYWCrsVZuLCKzAuFQeFNBnPDPRuPQxqaaTZ1Mg2yLxTQTxRv7vdedxvjCx9RV7Zjd4Q46bmc3fffp3DHpPrS46Qrz642iURjth4LDx2Poi52RWi9dwQ3EMCJt7kwxt4t7nnuP53jRRzATmrvkaUoxFNpsq5tBsy9pmiYX2u8hADPCUEsrBGcE8k

@mexemexe mexemexe changed the title [WIP] Add Comprehensive API Error Handling Documentation to README Add Comprehensive API Error Handling Documentation Jun 5, 2025
@mexemexe mexemexe marked this pull request as ready for review June 5, 2025 19:26
@riksnelders
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation Review

Description

Pull request contains only a README.md file with API error handling documentation, but lacks actual implementation and tests.

Recommendation

REJECT

Reasons:

  • No actual code implementation
  • No test files present
  • Documentation alone does not meet project requirements

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are in a single file in the /tests directory
  • No tests have been created
  • No actual code implementation exists

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests found

Missing Test Cases

  • Unit tests
  • Implementation tests

Action Items

  • Create a single implementation file in /src directory
  • Create a single test file in /tests directory
  • Implement the error handling functionality described in the README
  • Write comprehensive unit tests covering the implementation

Signatures

Staking Key

44B5n7BdnyKUKWhEg7pftFHaLg2oWx1zJE3sXkiadkXV: 3TaVfqc6gKuWdrdx4gFYTvwXLSLrreDCbZHZJdWXSYimUNiXa2wWSoG3AadFwCSdwKudenRnMjBkUVPs31TyqqumUXiiFHFKfhWyx9Xz2mT8X1dwGPym1hz6SLtVhnM7nqyR8f5xM7w6Q6YnNtJ5mix7oAVVpgq4gpXEPYznrAvisMLQQvDxKNo67bHxCrWZT5Z1NWjdZNDZYiTRdCzMgqYqXHnFCwmnu1QCXzF75KawH6bYvZBiqM4augerTxKXwjhKUdUhRue

Public Key

GGwS4JanHMAZwZGWGLtM1bH6vAzM2Ueu9fKNAeJH8CZt: 3enaqEgPUA8mdrpU4W1LzTwU8bckmt2F2Xjv1uDFVF7XQwAXB99xxxGvrwtfA917ziHdyEAjZVKp5v821zXTodueAyL26fojA2pLwtFDyDWznNqNNvGKyWg3wHVgTQXEmxw9R5hLw3D1SkC9XH1vVvVqU2mbUD5XXfkBctyQ2r98nY8kM8kiev3DGmoNfxjr1184bxWAN4Tbvs8oP9ptZgjEVtkR8pkMT5pGqDwBiMqsqbqhwtzAoyHBdpzi5VvECFVGPVsVPZe

@relayrelayrelay
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation Review

Description

The pull request contains a comprehensive README.md about API error handling, but does not meet the implementation requirements.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation is well-written but does not constitute a complete implementation
  • Missing source code and test files are critical
  • Project structure does not match specified requirements

Unmet Requirements

  • No implementation file in /src directory
  • No tests in /tests directory
  • README.md exists but is not an implementation

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests were found

Missing Test Cases

  • Implementation source code
  • Test files

Action Items

  • Create a single implementation file in /src directory
  • Create corresponding test file in /tests directory
  • Ensure implementation matches the error handling approach described in README.md
  • Implement core functionality with proper error handling

Signatures

Staking Key

BThUqRtMBgUdTQ9knVpEEuJuJDdCtw8WNzjLHQy26puz: RtxSQYM54dYxMChN4WDGahT1Xgxz6LZ7mz9gmxzvXVpvUniBT1DgHH3mANgrMSR1kpMxxaXh1rcWcQ8A9UoWaBVZqVk8HpnNPEtcsgZEBu4MGWWvV1rSo2GDHVxsD1jX1xwHdC3X2ZmhikA6XgPMAnNL4hvtX7nvo5YVCVAUPexUzaZu3i3zJpRXxiJTASDSzbvKuYgUkQb8WJ8ug2hNVaT2rpJLi9Tio8fpsFCqjtRS8EkY5zcYdaPsJwtigBYkhkYtZhSphi

Public Key

HzePbq1GWAqP9WDrJF7JPk65YN1myCcCsXn8QMtK4gZW: 45Bo3HqnedihJiQnX9rvosHga26Y7xWtqLarTYvsir9VQMQ4KJGKMbGesEJVpWLRnbUW7aT9nwM5pXgAsmaFrR7BUfVGVa8YsgsmFQ9R4DiP8XWpUBBXGd6barDEmbC1UThjkrTYKM2LHFSvQtmdBxBJEV8RxgtoGb4hxNVdKBoq2sUj7x347pgXWmhDPLbVAJoH4pPS7MVAi5LCbM7vGt3cGAEJY3t43sipiMxkbEXzxE5Po3No8sM7xWnwGbgwhjxxTkgayPi

@Alexdyn1927
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Documentation for API error handling, including error response structure, HTTP status codes, and best practices for error handling.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Comprehensive error handling documentation exists
  • Lacks actual implementation and test files
  • Missing code to accompany the documentation

Unmet Requirements

  • No implementation file in /src directory
  • No test file in /tests directory

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests found

Missing Test Cases

  • Implementation tests
  • Unit tests
  • Error handling tests

Action Items

  • Create an implementation file in /src directory that demonstrates the error handling described in the README
  • Add corresponding test files in /tests directory to validate error handling
  • Ensure implementation matches the error handling documentation

Signatures

Staking Key

EasyALNTzoKwgHMHDTnRfwXBSjqvfvghYDRzbrWsP54D: rD97NGeD4KL1LGnUTBHBqJ3BVpP3tKugZuXMMepUPTjAJRvqgd6UjXiR4Crpu7fhg7hxDX5PCNT9oiaURy6W4R9xNuY3fT6nrqR5mKZm4HsYK8asqyAJQzTJLdkpXHtdmybWUUSNrtxoBBffa6W1T2PrjyN7ZpGMrdxety3iXkxJHvX76cNWrq435qugJWaCRDFd2WEJoN34qxbnW2kGFfQpAJTi4GJagHGm6sttJ9ZchpXxuRHgKfva7QHUdZyUUxU72rcKpg

Public Key

3UXKxq2Y6pi2Zs71LKMnmssuA3JhjGsFRW1SsP9WRgTw: fuYautZtGHrWqLWdegWLAuNhJYvjzwrgHt9n54EJ8ZDsXEMBULNUXa59UuwVrh8x5K1Vt554vR2UUAJJaevYvEetjhLwgdPWF8pnScDLUtT61gApNR1hSCTT91DSYHSRqfyZGx9A131jeHC2K2UYoaeWb3kyQswyUYqfZzwM8wAQ69XMSCQoqWwpumZdTQ16aBMkKsM92ygxQGx7dLKfxGLfXTPmD2XHbgDXbrXQ8wcwcMfNfgEpYKvRMxCbxWSUajmo1J2f7J

@utukku77
Copy link
Owner

utukku77 commented Jun 5, 2025

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Pull request contains a detailed README about API error handling documentation.

Recommendation

REJECT

Reasons:

  • Submitted content is only documentation, not a code implementation
  • Does not meet basic requirements of having source and test files
  • No actual functional code or tests to review

Unmet Requirements

  • No implementation in /src directory
  • No tests in /tests directory
  • Missing actual code implementation
  • Lacks executable code and test files

Tests

Failed Tests

  • All test requirements

Missing Test Cases

  • Implementation files
  • Test files

Action Items

  • Create implementation in /src directory
  • Create corresponding tests in /tests directory
  • Ensure implementation matches documentation
  • Verify tests cover core functionality, edge cases, and error handling

Signatures

Staking Key

9sZLgvyCWub3q8JAdQcDhDEdePW4Tefv4PeqcoY1Caa1: 3ibEg9vUyehCTQ5ey8r34cBPfcwKG6WjuFdjetQa4McRCZaRVN8EJQTojR1DeNa99kD9LVQX3v7ngFi1FxdSUuxbccA1uuHR1XbxKwq3Efnryuy3gevNZxWs3hhPvxpCdxZaKVEAVsSQ5QJq3aXYeYP1t6HT2hvzHyje3xmBaUgfSx7NbRp7ytbCe4F5WMxDZYTAZyN8g8T63uV2xBPWBwKT9uzh1jT4qajqUv6zfHdfz4ewZFnsvq1d5rtA2NPRHF4CCCVmNyS

Public Key

BVJGcniy3f2wFv8LACVxSpxabREZ9Vq85DVJ1kavEjeo: 3hcS9sTj8Sya7YtfeHfwryWuWXzK5vjohNExfVrpm4ynpmQxBXqxfJuxL41GavyYgwN3KJ7iQMXa8caMc5rPe53ui6jzpki7sJSj4QcDo4KeBxdShBBpZwrZ3mGeWA1EJcDym4zS38KpwWrFyptpp2e5hNWz2Vo4k9Fk18wAFZYbm8aBG5XmEDFFzjxeaS2JWbz2CGCBb2zKKudReCDrFoooD7nrk5uM8y7vuhNoRSnG2AcSMmmi6YKMLtNE95C53VEHEkfQRPA

@modemjak
Copy link

modemjak commented Jun 5, 2025

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Pull request adds comprehensive API error handling documentation to the README.md file.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • The pull request contains only a README.md file with API error handling documentation
  • No actual implementation or tests are present
  • Documentation looks well-structured and comprehensive

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is not in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are not in a single file in the /tests directory
  • No implementation file found

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests found

Missing Test Cases

  • Implementation file
  • Test files

Action Items

  • Create a /src directory and add an implementation file
  • Create a /tests directory and add corresponding test files
  • Ensure the implementation matches the error handling described in the README

Signatures

Staking Key

61j3xcDoN24mXbvESMXsrwvq3Jo4m1XJp9ubWaw6Cq2Q: 38aa3VjsuqQxRN36wffXXf1i8nQbd8JSXaFQevJbQnXHD6HhLNrmr44tKpEG22atrja1jK5tgkN2vygRPwTGTQE5VVsiAYoYBvDPm7xBukJ1CjXnpUuzrxqk8hbYtSQvTtoT4oFgnFGhCRQtKLaeu9zfQfKeM2X8PQMwbrZzGZ2agJQCznhgyuFkk8bg9rq18rSMNoUd79QeWenxmRMKARePRpoUx5WcEcKzcoVhf7kRdwUmNrmBRXYKzsXAdHuiqbp6TrTvt4U

Public Key

uBniFJW3kUNWc4tCDrYK75VMv98rgSfaH5yCumPzPUQ: 3Fuj9RJJEPCr18SGrTRJ2PqTohKXCjgs2F2EsjfyFKHXedKVLmngPSr82Z2xzRVQZRq1Jvnuz6MMmirqcGrT9ep8nTCnn6LqddUqt8znHtbqipTqphSrtpDbh1b31Vnj5AV6quQNrvwMv6ZzgEhEFYBDxjgELj2ZSnXruxHRBqSiPQwWrNyxTMnHmpnLbpmxnjAYonkprAGcwUhcTPAytULgcye6N54gtu2zzE8qVgkeNwbUReFnkk4EARjuTsBhU599GPWV3aC

@SatoshiShibanuma
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Comprehensive documentation for API error handling, including error response structure, HTTP status codes, and best practices.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation exists but lacks implementation and test files
  • README provides good error handling guidelines
  • Missing source code and test verification

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are in a single file in the /tests directory

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No test files found

Missing Test Cases

  • Implementation files
  • Test files

Action Items

  • Create /src directory with implementation file
  • Create /tests directory with corresponding test file
  • Implement the error handling logic described in the README
  • Add unit tests to verify error handling scenarios

Signatures

Staking Key

67sMTqztouCV7JyxbXwE9ukZw7DkzpGQ7SWFa26uEKiu: 4KotBc8ZHGBCmoC9ZtooxxD3cSZiMgxvJc9cEgKFWAzqR25K2ZsG74XmkdxcXZcgNGTAnFpHguuXu1LD1hBh5gTX1i7kSY5E7xpkNj3jbAA1CaF5y5ELdfpdUmxAfJ8FikVDjKBV2wXUBfMBZEH7yWmQ8vaFFug4x6YNq9SUqprofwevJin98jaDWvcNruV4jVS3HnhJBSGDja622QBw5xnau1vttqjRmyYhVG9Ewfi2ErKdk9s1boZvhAPut9vcLiNbVAEtnk4

Public Key

3BQfPXJnnVjRidUnzVWY4SQiEQw7dJGQdAA2xQfYxFQe: 3Vik7naP4Eh3D5attKddi2xYpXfcf5jhGUW8av1d1i3MK7AhtngcGPvpEmxs1eoRJnpk2rfsZfFcdxbqV9vnWTJ1f3V6PNvBWZCvBh6MHYt72zEY33MnB5m9oReuT5wFPqx7QRPeDS4Qh99nu2VP7K4xcMnR2PNLbviqXuMwWLkBEEgkjVJ5y1U2n7e2HKaj2yCwtrZbG1J2kyZ6Y17c7jyFFtXvSRu2E3Xc5nsLQyYhMMbV5desKNc71g3JCGhRQdvaGVZJuk8

@ranjhayhero
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Added comprehensive documentation for API error handling, including error response structure, HTTP status codes, error handling best practices, and example scenarios.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation looks comprehensive and well-structured
  • Missing implementation and test files in src and tests directories

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • tests are in a single file in the /tests directory

Tests

Failed Tests

No failing tests

Missing Test Cases

  • src directory
  • tests directory

Action Items

  • Create a /src directory and add implementation file
  • Create a /tests directory and add corresponding test file
  • Ensure implementation matches the error handling documentation

Signatures

Staking Key

HUjFCWMEK2VxfsrCpayemKNcsvvevebHnM8xDRqPH6os: 32Ufe2rFPHgY9a4y8qA78CgAL3ZkSHmcacfBw5m9yvnUa9f5otdfSodDbRk8v7ShYQc3h3mMC14k9zgWy4wgEHrqc76DTUsv3D7BY4Q3UftEQmSKP6Q6iN4N8qc3uJRR5xXjmsqoCpqX9cmbzyS1C1iM6NpEY3GsjwndjWB9QooruXZHexfbS3aDQnz55ZRLbKseCvuzNmgafMwbsQztRot2cSqVpwtrsDy8BUiAP5XNxddcy8NWbXLELdYw95uKXeUpK7texgt

Public Key

21bw5w1jncJHRHNs2CwqSGC2JRdMVFPHx9F1nyMLQ61C: 4JNZKJDF43DM3wKJBrpcnWVNqEK916KqBBJYCUkxkfi567uKHwcXnvBeP1Ft9PqPjUZJBQfy1m23Ku5uBGNh7MUkxxUtxvGxP8DGLkrQneqAUi84NsSs4fJhuiDNp5YVk6eYtFzhDSse9pyeE6eEqMXonUYortSmKoGr8dABgAKKs7A1qCX4YY7VhH2cA2LFiW3C6xPiSfKvjhcKXS2BrLHFLRC2UZ8Su94Lqpi8dLKcAkx2Jy3num1nhytJBy89AGAkpLAu7XA

@sopheakim
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Documentation for API error handling, including error response structure, HTTP status codes, and best practices for error management.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation looks comprehensive and well-structured
  • Lacks implementation files in /src directory
  • No tests have been created
  • Currently only contains README documentation

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are in a single file in the /tests directory
  • No tests have been provided

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests found

Missing Test Cases

  • Unit tests
  • Integration tests

Action Items

  • Create a single implementation file in /src directory
  • Create a single test file in /tests directory
  • Implement unit tests for error handling scenarios
  • Add integration tests for API error handling

Signatures

Staking Key

8hAhdRrEs8mbVnN2douviNWjQ2xXgeb31KQNAa2yTbVg: 49veAuh3uy9UxCJTAYFGo3Awc8W6pPreoXZmtYAFoC1RcAYhHTWYZ3HRCfShVY8ioNDtyFFBneJhHd3f3evwhoNQApNCDyteMhm7t12emaQuRxzHvUYboPepoysJ8FGoAaugjVVDxtG7kmybcayZQwQLwiG3G3yY6a3CeAH36DRj2RCEbEsbcxLuTuikYpr5AR2ArwaHBEjyTeGZTo1oeYjtUjJNycnzbvWDLPw1TAWjFfV5yobwcT6fk2i6z1hUGX6zMV9nUd2

Public Key

43bZxBBPosBCxfy982VaGcrTgT3Ff4wwK3hcZSEXGVUn: 3BVRwoe29my3gZG32R28MmaaZTG1R3y66ctZq15dHa82fdvHXbp2nwgD7zJEJWKRRc3cVM7xoToRoqwAjB9cX4oP6gm7wmzcYqkJYguxj42yXNDo4UGztdcvH29nLyuAthC33okNKVCnG9Ea23MiXh23beZov8SQQSeTKVvDRhzacceR8CgEJwPDxKK9YiTPmBxeRXG65XvGhnYBdDFos53x9EvpmfJV82nG7q8JU9snAqGvMnVjpSAy7MQjZJQmEJo3ehjr7KA

@Mutaawe1
Copy link

Mutaawe1 commented Jun 5, 2025

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Pull request adds comprehensive API error handling documentation to the README.md file.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation looks good, but implementation files are missing
  • No source code or test files in required directories

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are in a single file in the /tests directory

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No test files found

Missing Test Cases

  • src implementation
  • tests directory

Action Items

  • Create /src directory and add implementation file
  • Create /tests directory and add test file
  • Implement core functionality based on error handling documentation
  • Write comprehensive tests covering error scenarios

Signatures

Staking Key

ECSCannUZAkurh76cQ37PpQUXCsGcueeF3i8wcinHh9g: 4EUwbwmXLBghvFgy68dYKUX94Si262Mw4aULdZMoFMuGApz2HHWSeR2KGeT2SXwNEoQryy5Byi9dnQoQin1joNSZfoCCcEjYsVL1WBhtrGQdWavpJCDSd86Gn7e6QQL4Zia7XadGasS6rPrWqcejGNddYVVm6wREfrcvFB47YWPegJ21VgdRrLja5oeL27bgtYNDw5eQjRc987Vm3WJ1r6e5jesU2EL4yw3meqvki7FV7pxmraPohBx5ZLzNz2Gqy9wND1szUAY

Public Key

2yy9cpNXXd76CMrENH87xdC68fZQJxPG4iabNqj8wQsS: ufdNgAehhTUGASVqH8K6RC23wT6PweGKYz75WovpJVGoRBYFabg21MLDcYSfuHMKhmci4iqybYM83hFTbDbEdtgxYk8j3dcG8PxawJUPrVXHRC8whG8Q2fkwSzBrNPA1kC12hjnxXCpNbdwhs83aYGCXqcju4ABgWhNGR57JKm31M7KuSvAM41DJdTTGDNBiofBFLA65FYAfi6C4y3b7gYMtwnTkpxFaFQ71WMvWxkMYSugtf4NRnkZd5a8HSPLGwdSxFvSYbv

@Donfelippee
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Documentation for API error handling, including error response structure, HTTP status codes, and best practices for error handling.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation looks comprehensive
  • Missing actual implementation and tests
  • Requires creation of source and test directories

Unmet Requirements

  • No implementation in /src directory
  • No tests in /tests directory
  • Cannot verify unit test passing

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests found

Missing Test Cases

  • Implementation tests
  • Error handling tests

Action Items

  • Create /src directory with implementation file
  • Create /tests directory with corresponding test file
  • Implement unit tests for error handling scenarios
  • Ensure tests cover different error cases described in documentation

Signatures

Staking Key

2Qe1tVLF7kGG2zSoH4sVGXEvu9rP3a9Y5MEJCjExTBGV: 3YStCbVpVvuufhzkp6mZoG9tCzdfpM3tP82irCmfhJ1eBro4LLjkJhoaXKCNxNTCzdkWpuAS9F1RxgFS7UgJ39WnAjXc2hLdov6QmQutPm8U3oG6Ynu8PtyoR8Tow9Xa7qM8HWbs5n3fsXVsBGwP7LNz4kJdTGXgqKkiRv516kw6pvR1txKxwyGiE2Wtbb5G2foxNG9wZ8zW5zkUFBJLwVP87NxDqFfJ7XeJhP2YF1yvnJH3sYLBnvc4AtUmvLmYoUS3xsYTzse

Public Key

6erw3Vk9LLZxXV77sSfrwNGoChLPqpmRTdbvsWjURzVA: gBU5vP5tYNZ5q1urFyfZ9x12RrcKHTodFDyjQ87VUfMnx82WXNhLx7ze2aLEh6HWCFx7nWSKRHDEBFLCPkyN74DKHjw4rYS2nnm6Gj5gUrECpMqZgfpq9KU8afksEFzG4NHeG1ZXfnYC33FV6kXzuvw4abaLJZChEbaLnhhDuDH5dYz93dVBmcrNrBspGUe7CELqjL9LTxV7kAdZp5UbsJfNA426J95cDbSqKoTT3vW1er6E8UDJ9mSjPmuEB4XqnwaPRUrPvC

@LearnHD
Copy link

LearnHD commented Jun 5, 2025

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Pull request adds comprehensive API error handling documentation to the project README.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation looks well-structured and comprehensive
  • Missing implementation files in /src directory
  • No test files in /tests directory

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are in a single file in the /tests directory
  • No unit tests provided

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests found

Missing Test Cases

  • Unit tests
  • Source code implementation

Action Items

  • Create a /src directory with a source file implementing the documented error handling
  • Create a /tests directory with corresponding unit tests
  • Ensure tests cover the error handling scenarios described in the documentation

Signatures

Staking Key

EneX3W6ko45B6NfuXut7HVGFCx1SEFuVEhmkoHaRWVtf: HMTPxqJPMmCDwLm6W3rys7fzsCaxVYLpAPiDmWmCKsS69VYesV7kkdHkdqZZ4ohQddC21ytSP4JenZiRv7MaveJzC9Q2TnFVqK19udgV9eYGgNGYfGA8aL9gRQ2n2Tqm2RwZPHp6PMXjTSAXqjY3n8bYPTfLSEnhtABXC2HUxzPhSx5fbgdNP25SWZvEmfLRPEJEEVazXedHbfdGKsuqHSJCaVUPP8c6SZANNkybvZL5rS8XpBbM3x26JAV4q6qq4UohrVpEDz

Public Key

4J9StZv3hsEBcDJocdasRoroQJ5EQQYzfr2Xto3JstAo: 2g2fr14wtKMSDChmsHZTKMoBqz82ubzFAUS391jgquvFZ6AejybqN9JJ3krJWLB62Jcd4eDxd7PrqBFHQx5yaSyn8fR26mmAivAUfNfUDQwbmkefPMxk5NwuaHNH4wDErDzXMuDwNWm5t65Hr1F39S2fBZaTx3bPWj13nmZjvmtetyyUa5WTAkhbW9aBHNFj1udiPWyvjQLjDtd3CTxWWaX2eXtraAYytwX9hthVEfWLxQ42Wq421sazav5jLqYCnhM8eHsSAVS

@gapcomputer
Copy link

API Error Handling Documentation Review

Description

Pull request contains a README.md with API error handling documentation

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation exists but no actual implementation
  • Missing source code and test files
  • Repository structure does not match requirements

Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are in a single file in the /tests directory
  • No other files are modified

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests present

Missing Test Cases

  • Source code implementation
  • Test files

Action Items

  • Create a /src directory with implementation file
  • Create a /tests directory with corresponding test file
  • Implement the error handling mechanisms described in the README
  • Add unit tests to validate error handling strategies

Signatures

Staking Key

GaAX5SsXwQtnAZpYuM8xiQy6jT6y45ZwceSDM44YmRDC: 3HotrwRJ2rzx2XjaYLJPQHQFx5dWej4DDAUCJoAkowTAfnBAJi8nVa5dJ9BNiPW6qpLC2WS9yb2JE2pfkFcaXkUGbvcjwtWXvPUbFzL6fXBBY3FGq44STynGFWqtKd9oaiYajK9YrdTsVxUdDLxXssZBMrXkfbfZsKoJ35ereSn4K23GwE94k4jLisYyD4VpqQ1KpXxahjc3uoqkMiKYvzSUzQ576mCpo3HXYWJ8i8QGYF3amAGMSXHtToW3QfL9yZ7XgRwRqpx

Public Key

HUqT8zPGT5GXD98yLtdhg35nBeSMJgZoHW26vXQkDe7o: 3PZurARCAdSNoRU1thRCWq5d4vWcV7S2v2eg9wdT82LyBEBERB26kHqHvs1muT4QmkAhDCWhWqaxZ3xyuLLLBczkufavc7hpvw6pYJMau75YySb8dGEmUQjKtaVQ63yAV1pqAPzquRw4VAdqs9L8MzuFnnU1oo1DEWubuQGGYCFEeMH6WnpXkf36UA7HQyqcJyZL3du21LBJwFxSxca1qpdG3pDvo2HSoxWq1EkaTFnw48vf74MR66z6wZoyzEKwgcStkZ1TSWQ

@Vuk7912
Copy link

Vuk7912 commented Jun 5, 2025

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Documentation for API error handling, including status codes, error response structure, and best practices for error handling.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Documentation looks comprehensive and well-structured
  • Missing implementation and test files
  • Cannot verify actual functionality without code implementation

Unmet Requirements

  • No src directory with implementation
  • No tests directory with unit tests
  • Implementation is not in a single file in /src
  • No test files in /tests

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No tests found

Missing Test Cases

  • Unit tests
  • Implementation tests

Action Items

  • Create a /src directory with the API error handling implementation
  • Create a /tests directory with comprehensive unit tests
  • Implement error handling logic matching the documentation
  • Add test cases covering different error scenarios described in the README

Signatures

Staking Key

3oBzgQ4y8YtmkxYGkse1fKKefi25twpMKU9BBdsYtjDQ: 3r1zPj3JBoXsgkYDKHQv8tmdF3ue7VEeSo7kfAEt1VUpSJVQRHEGqGcdg7uYiTAPT5CVTcRgH8sY3UY5JmMVdZc7NyZNte4PaZsKhp51LpY4ciiZQhiWqtALAFnfNjoBavWxi7EwPihEgtdcjbUv1yV29bsAMUnb139C2c6HAj88KFt91b6iUb55XcQS9SuCYuJN2D1qs4GffwWeeNRv4zKEXzR6zvppPuSBms5s9PFG7y9JR6tA6jbjg7eHX6wsadjvMWC3HjS

Public Key

4WA5vRJLthsg6sJqVc6DQuRkGzvoxZ11SkqzwbqxCo2V: 2G9k2buFtGLQZtQP9FQJ2p8dx2zAejX4QSBfXpT1psCauao8r9cbWpw7WWiKGXjwH2RTAGPt6yJhQEa2Zi6YCNarXC4xW5t9L3vGgg9NZwJeSpeq7oEZymjoS93TTVPWiqxUYXGtwMn55kWnvyozGPJc3kfNz7QpbgPa5ukZzWqd1hj2GP3NkGq6XzVjgRpW2NvgxJhGsqjzpN3x6qB5ekkGiNjfLjKfaweQLsDGEJYDPC3Eqf9pYfXusyCbTGfRQjJJusK9ijN

@xLDVx
Copy link

xLDVx commented Jun 5, 2025

API Error Handling Documentation

Description

Pull request adds comprehensive API error handling documentation to the README.md file.

Recommendation

REVISE

Reasons:

  • Comprehensive error handling documentation is present
  • Missing implementation and test files
  • Documentation exists but lacks corresponding code files

Unmet Requirements

  • No /src directory with implementation
  • No /tests directory with tests

Tests

Failed Tests

  • No implementation files
  • No test files

Missing Test Cases

  • src/implementation.py
  • tests/test_implementation.py

Action Items

  • Create /src directory
  • Create /tests directory
  • Add implementation file in /src
  • Add corresponding test file in /tests

Signatures

Staking Key

He88p8gayqrGSWqpj7Mu4XzqcKsURDjnuK1z2UMnio3A: 4NY9W19bZFznSRvfYAWUUQ7Wn8DhgUqrS9sW2rVGUiskTasxWnFhMGfAcxAvfLZsF98Tf7YoodtQ6n3YnmxYo8SnhpEbBof3FgYRKQ3bz9qqssGmnCesgp7vP7V9pZJr9MCvGUa65wbz718cQMcFvG6hWvnK2hU2XoZkK9MzaFjHM5xXSSQzERGzAx4dEasE6XLFqDhLvnphpgXzjJkz1Me57Pk8YTjSQrgHy6AwjJywZ64NdDpUj6q2cfkhVHYqDUsrTYmkJw6

Public Key

FVeknmSZKTCvd8fxFxt5T4mQgxED2QhYBZyexLyCrrB8: 3nA8fFa89Vr4LxZ5NNeftC17AfRZSzD5y3WHWgRiCkEnhxcgQLFwUy5wZqgZfPx1jH3o26Z7PYdUcs2t9mvQ8RsXY63riqwVfucpbLQYdkffi5BeRNegGHRembjj8kSfqNwP3mYmNAGssztsjVXTwED1qNgu5z7yzA7ndW3pmjvMgU1BhCjLrSFFJ8NpSuVbb2PbewEP44Gc1xMeHSZZtxDrqa7VFKDkwtghgTkoPEomhxqf8PqHZ9tq4TVr1sVt6mBE5TVmsEc

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.